In This Moment is one of early 21st century America's best metal bands. They didn't start out that way, though. On the band's debut CD,
Beautiful Tragedy, they were a regulation semi-overwrought metalcore outfit with a female singer. But on 2008's
The Dream, they allowed pop-oriented producer
Kevin Churko (who'd worked with
Ozzy Osbourne,
Celine Dion, and
Shania Twain) to bring out their melodic side, and let vocalist
Maria Brink demonstrate that she could really sing, not just scream more or less in tune. The fusion of metalcore and retro-minded arena pop-metal worked very well, and on
A Star-Crossed Wasteland, they up their game again, recording some of their hardest, heaviest songs ("Gun Show," "Just Drive," "Blazin'") alongside some truly beautiful ballads like the closing, piano-led "World in Flames." On "The Promise," a male vocalist,
Adrian Patrick of the band
Otherwise, duets with
Brink, each one switching back and forth between clean and harsh vocals. The result sounds a lot like
Lacuna Coil, but with more emotional power than the occasionally distant Europeans. Established fans of
In This Moment will love
A Star-Crossed Wasteland, but as their best album, it's also a perfect introduction for a newcomer. ~ Phil Freeman