Any project in the works for two decades is bound to generate its fair share of myths and so it is with
Neil Young's
Archives, a series of a multi-disc box sets chronicling
Young's history. Originally envisioned in the late '80s as a
Decade II, the project quickly mutated into a monster covering every little corner of
Neil's career. With its escalation came delays, so many that it sometimes seemed that the project never really existed; it was just a shared fantasy between
Neil and his faithful. During that long, long wait, fans held tight to the idea that
Archives was a clearinghouse of rarities similar to
Bob Dylan's
The Bootleg Series, a treasure trove of unreleased songs and epochal live performances that would trump whatever bootleggers had to offer. While rare and unheard music is certainly a key part of
Archives, particularly on the first disc covering the pre-history of 1963-1965, viewing this project as merely a CD box set is wildly misleading.
Neil Young has designed
Archives as nothing less than an immersive multimedia autobiography, an interactive experience where the music, text, video, and pictures feed off each other, creating a virtual journey through
Neil's past.
Because this is a biography,
Archives, Vol. 1 winds up relying very heavily on previously released recordings, containing almost all of Neil Young,
Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere,
After the Gold Rush, and
Harvest, key
Buffalo Springfield and
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young cuts, and the previously released archival live albums
Live at the Fillmore East 1970 and Live at Massey Hall 1971. Such a large chunk of familiar material is bound to disappoint any listener expecting
Archives to be a rarities-only set, forgetting that its origin was as a sequel to
Decade, the triple-LP set that mixed up hits with unreleased tunes.
Archives follows a similar blueprint, excavating many rare gems -- some, like "Bad Fog of Loneliness" quite familiar to bootleggers; some, like an extraordinary "Dance Dance Dance" cut with
Graham Nash, not -- and placing them neatly alongside his well-known jewels, so the end effect isn't a rush of discovery but ongoing quiet revelation, an impression underpinned by the set's leisurely pace.
The entire
Archives is designed to trace
Neil's evolution, to explain how his dead ends were really detours and how his mood swings weren't all that wild; it preserves
Young's history as he perceived it. To that end, the DVD and especially BluRay editions of the set are essential to understanding both the project and
Neil himself, so much so that the CD edition feels almost like an afterthought, a skimming of the surface of a deep lake. Often,
Young delayed
Archives due to the limits of technology, a claim that seemed no more than an excuse to keep the project incomplete, but
Archives in its BluRay incarnation lives up to all of
Neil's promises over the years, coming close to collecting everything -- lyrics, press, artwork, TV performances, doodles, scraps of every sort -- in one place, letting users linger for as long as they'd like in a specific era. Surely, the sound quality on BluRay is extraordinary -- the music leaps out of the speakers yet never sounds overly clean, digital, or modern -- but it's the interactive nature of the set that impresses most. While the DVD set also is complexly interactive, BluRay is designed to be continually updated via the Internet, so
Young can add songs and videos whenever he wants, placing the new material as a virtual pushpin on each disc's time line. Acting as a supplement to the text biographies on each disc -- the biography only covering the years on the disc -- the time line places
Young's evolution on a broader scale and is illuminated by this extra material, such as a downright thrilling
CSNY performance of "Down by the River" on ABC-TV, but this is merely a teaser for the main event: the virtual filing cabinet, where every song on the set has its own folder bulging with handwritten lyrics, press clips, photos, snippets of in-concert introductions, alternate takes -- the list is almost endless and it's always different, so it's easy to flip back to a song and discover a bunch of information you missed the first time around. Add to this, there are an untold number of Easter eggs, sometimes housing the best stuff here, such as videos of
Young combing through the archives and reminiscing in 1997, or a 15-minute film clip of
Young discovering a
CSNY bootleg while record shopping in the early '70s and then taking it from the store.
This level of detail may suggest the one serious flaw in
Archives: it cannot be taken casually. It demands complete, undivided attention, requiring users to dig as deep as they'd like, and it's no stretch to say that it could take a week or two to discover everything here. Also, the set comes so tantalizingly close to being complete, it's a major irritation to have one song lopped off of each the albums; surely, the extra storage space on DVD and BluRay could have allowed for complete runs of
Everybody,
Gold Rush, and
Harvest. But really, these complaints feel churlish when faced with a box that is an embarrassment of riches, offering so much more than anybody could have imagined during that long, long wait. Not only was the wait worth it,
Archives feels like it was 20 years in the making. It's an extraordinary work that redefines what an autobiography can be. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine