Electric Circus cost and won
Common some fans. It was very exploratory, especially so for a rap album released in 2002, containing developments -- some of which soared, some of which sank -- that few longtime followers could have foreseen. Listeners either felt
Common was picking up fresh, new inspirations, or that he was just being distracted by a whole lot of ill-fitting nonsense. With
Be, it seems the MC has realized that not every album that's sprawling and eclectic is as good as
Electric Ladyland or
Songs in the Key of Life. More notably, he might've been struck with the fact that a high percentage of excellent albums are around 40 minutes in length and are built on a unified sound.
Be is highly concentrated, containing 11 songs and involving two producers and a small number of guests. It's a 180 degree turn from
Electric Circus, and in a bizarre way it's both a progression and a back-to-basics move.
Kanye West and
Dilla are key to the album's steadiness, rooting the sound in '70s soul and soul-jazz. That's no shakeup, but the two producers deserve some form of award for stringing together a consistent sequence of productions that is never monotonous, dull, or all that flashy. Even lead single "The Corner," heard well before
Be's release, falls into the fabric of the album on first listen, as if that were where it belonged all along. Lyrically,
Common comes back down to Earth -- the narratives are sharp as ever, the gripes are more like observations than screeds, and the eccentricities need to be teased out rather than swatted away.
Be isn't likely to be referred to by anyone as groundbreaking, but it's one of
Common's best, and it's also one of the most tightly constructed albums of any form within recent memory. ~ Andy Kellman