Other than the album's genre-crossing premise, there's nothing particularly gimmicky or flashy about bluegrass singer/songwriter
Chris Thile and jazz pianist
Brad Mehldau's 2017 Nonesuch collaboration,
Chris Thile & Brad Mehldau. Simply put,
Thile and
Mehldau deliver a set of deeply engaging, organically realized songs that perfectly balance their respective jazz and bluegrass skills. Given that they seemingly come from polar ends of the musical spectrum, the collaboration may feel like an odd choice at first. However, after hearing this debut, one might be hard-pressed to imagine a more compatible duo to emerge from their generation than these two distinctive mavericks. The similarities have always been there; both musicians started out as purist arbiters of their prospective roots-based genres, but later transitioned into leading proponents of their own progressive, harmonically nuanced musical ideologies.
Thile broke the mold when he started incorporating pop, folk, and traditional bluegrass with
Nickel Creek, a permutable instinct later underlined with his nods to rock and fusion with
the Punch Brothers. Similarly, while
Mehldau is often justifiably compared to jazz icons like
Keith Jarrett and
Bill Evans, his reconceptualization of alt-rock hits by
Radiohead and
Nirvana, combined with his deft improvisational skill, long marked him as a gentle jazz radical. This inkling that both artists shared a philosophical and aesthetic sensibility is apparently exactly what motivated executive producer and label president
Robert Hurwitz to introduce the two to each other after a
Punch Brothers show several years prior to this album. Subsequently,
Thile and
Mehldau began playing together casually, purportedly developing a strong rapport. Based on the songs here, that rapport sounds effortless, as they warmly intertwine both their instruments and voices on covers like a rambling take on
Bob Dylan's "Don't Think Twice, It's All Right" and an evocative reworking of
Joni Mitchell's "Marcie." One minute,
Mehldau is framing
Thile's yearning vocals in soft, velvety chords and the next,
Thile is comping with furious intensity on his mandolin as
Mehldau launches into a cascading solo. The duo's original songs are also quite fascinating, particularly the
Eric Clapton-esque "The Old Shade Tree" and the poetic, classically inflected "Noise Machine," inspired by the recent birth of
Thile's first child. These are deeply hued, literate songs, as personal as anything either artist has done, yet delivered with an almost startlingly robust virtuosity. Even when they defy expectations, as when
Thile sets down his mandolin for a piano-accompanied reading of the standard "I Cover the Waterfront," or when they eschew lyrics for an instrumental version of
Elliott Smith's "Independence Day," there's a palpable sense of real listening, of generously shared creativity. Ultimately, it's that synergistic spark that makes
Thile and
Mehldau's collaboration sound less like a one-off experiment and more like the start of a lasting partnership. ~ Matt Collar