When
Sister Sledge recorded their debut album,
Circle of Love, in 1974, all four members of the group were still in their teens --
Debbie Sledge, the oldest member, was 19, while the youngest,
Kathy, was only 15. However, there's nothing bubblegum about
Circle of Love. If
Sister Sledge sounded like a female equivalent of the early
Jackson 5 on 1973's "Mama Never Told Me," this vinyl LP found the Philadelphians sounding more like a younger version of
the Three Degrees (who were also from Philly). This LP had a gem of a single in the haunting "Love, Don't You Go Through No Changes on Me," which wasn't huge but did reach number 31 on the R&B charts. The rest of the album isn't that strong, nor is it in a class with
Sister Sledge's late-'70s/early-'80s work with
Chic and
Narada Michael Walden. Nonetheless, it's a decent, if uneven, collection of Philly soul, and the siblings handle themselves well on material ranging from the
Gamble & Huff-minded "Pain Reliever" and the charming "Cross My Heart" to the
Thom Bell/
Linda Creed ballad "Give in to Love."
Circle of Love isn't among
Sister Sledge's essential albums, but it has historic value and deserves attention from fans. ~ Alex Henderson