When DGC Records signed
Nirvana in 1991, one of DGC's A&R reps expressed the opinion that, with plenty of touring and the right promotion, the new act might sell as well as its labelmate and touring partner
Sonic Youth. The surprise success of
Nevermind upended previous commercial expectations for
Sonic Youth (among other established alternative rock bands), and when
Dirty was released in 1992, it was seen by many as the band's big move toward the grunge market. Which doesn't make a lot of sense if you actually listen to the album; while
Butch Vig's clean but full-bodied production certainly gave
Thurston Moore and
Lee Ranaldo's guitars greater punch and presence than they had in the past, and many of the songs move in the increasingly tuneful direction the band had been traveling with
Daydream Nation and
Goo, most of
Dirty is good bit more jagged and purposefully discordant than its immediate precursors, lacking the same hallucinatory grace as
Daydream Nation or the hard rock sheen of
Goo. If anything,
Dirty finds
Sonic Youth revisiting the territory the band mapped out on
Sister -- merging the propulsive structures of rock (both punk and otherwise) with the gorgeous chaos of their approach to the electric guitar -- and it shows how much better they'd gotten at it in the past five years, from the curiously beautiful "Wish Fulfillment" and "Theresa's Sound World" to the brutal "Drunken Butterfly" and "Purr."
Dirty was also
Sonic Youth's most overtly political album, railing against the abuses of the Reagan/Bush era on "Youth Against Fascism," "Swimsuit Issue," and "Chapel Hill," a surprising move from a band so often in love with cryptic irony. Heard today,
Dirty doesn't sound like a masterpiece (like
Daydream Nation) or a gesture toward the mainstream audience (like
Goo) -- it just sounds like a damn good rock album, and on those terms it ranks with
Sonic Youth's best work. ~ Mark Deming