Richard Swift threw his dice down a lo-fi Tin Pan Alley on the
Novelist/Walking Without Effort, a collection of sepia-toned curios that spanned 2001 to 2004 but sounded like visionary pop acetates from the 1904 World's Fair. The native Minnesotan and closet anglophile taps his cane down "Penny Lane" on
Dressed Up for the Letdown, a warm and deceptively inviting celebration of post-
Revolver "Fab Four" ("Kisses for the Misses" is pure, amiable
McCartney despair).
Swift's laconic delivery is often compared to contemporaries like
Ron Sexsmith and
Rufus Wainwright, but when he tosses off self-directed barbs like "I played your heart but I broke two strings Jesus Christ, you're a lovely thing" from the swooning "Buildings in America," it's a
Ray Davies or
Elvis Costello comparison that he's more deserving of. While the album as a whole does wallow a bit, it never suffers melodically. The
Richard Hawley-esque "Ballad of You Know Who" may conjure up images of a cocktail-cherry-covered beverage napkin, but it feels more like a wink than a teardrop, the ambling title cut perks up as a ghostly horn trio wanders in from the cold, and the cabaret-style closer paints John the Baptist as "The Opening Band" for Jesus Christ.
Dressed Up for the Letdown feels like the wee hours of morning, and that may keep some listeners from breaking it out as often as they should, but like all good slices of melancholy pie, it's best enjoyed in your basement while the rest of the world is asleep. ~ James Christopher Monger