A giant step beyond
the Blake Babies' scattershot 1987 debut, Nicely Nicely, 1989's
Earwig is an utter delight. Although it was recorded during a period of personnel instability, before the group had once and for all settled into the trio format of
Juliana Hatfield on bass and vocals,
John P. Strohm on guitar, and Freda Boner on drums, there's a cohesion to this album that makes it greater than the sum of its individual parts. Opening with the mildly petulant ecological rant "Cesspool," the album quickly settles into the niche that would remain
the Blake Babies' for the rest of their career: first-person songs about life among the young and disenchanted. "You Don't Give Up," "Don't Suck My Breath," and the sneering "Take Your Head off My Shoulder" initiate the rocky relationship with romance that's the hallmark of
Hatfield's lyrics, and songs like the moody, almost ambient "From Here to Burma" indicate a wider frame of musical reference than many groups of their ilk. Though the band would quickly outshine it with the mini-masterpiece
Sunburn,
Earwig was the album on which
the Blake Babies proved that they were among the most important groups on the nascent indie rock underground. ~ Stewart Mason