It is difficult to fairly compare this recording of the National Youth Orchestra of Wales to professional ensembles. Despite the immense skill of the orchestra, it is still a youth group that simply does not yield an entirely satisfying performance. Balance is hands down the number one issue with which to contend. The orchestra boasts 30 violins, yet only 5 violas, with similar mismatches in other sections. No amount of audio engineering can totally smooth out discrepancies like that. Intonation is generally quite good, as is ensemble unity. Overall tone quality, however, is just lackluster and immature.
What this recording does have going for it, though, is the presentation of two orchestral works that are almost never heard: the Symphony No. 2 of
Edward Elgar and the Investiture Dances by the little-known composer Alun Hoddinott. Neither of these compositions is likely to be burning up concert stages anytime soon, though. The
Elgar Symphony pales in comparison to other works from his oeuvre, such as the cello concerto and Enigma Variations. So check out this CD if you're curious about what some of the world's young musicians are capable of, or if you're truly curious about two pieces of music you're not likely to hear many other places; however, don't buy it if you're hoping for a profoundly satisfying musical experience.