Everybody Digs Bill Evans was a landmark recording for the young pianist and sported a unique album cover, featuring written-out endorsements from
Miles Davis,
George Shearing,
Ahmad Jamal, and
Cannonball Adderley. At a time approximate to when
Evans was performing with the famous
Kind of Blue band of
Davis,
Adderley, and
John Coltrane, and actually departing the band,
Evans continued to play the trio music he was ultimately best known for. With the unmatched pair of former
Miles Davis drummer
Philly Joe Jones and bassist
Sam Jones (no relation),
Evans was emerging not only as an ultra-sensitive player, but as an interpreter of standards second to none. The drummer is quite toned down to match the dynamics of the session, while the ever-reliable bassist lays back even more than usual, but at the expense of his soul. Of the covers, the solo "Lucky to Me" and the melancholy "What Is There to Say?" with the trio evoke the cool, smoldering emotionalism
Evans was known for. He's even more starkly reserved on his solo version of "Young and Foolish." But
Evans also knows how to play vigorous bop, tearing up the complicated "Oleo," and he modestly tackles the
Gigi Gryce icon "Minority," though if you listen closely, the takes are slightly imprecise and a bit thin.
Evans is hyperactive on a clattery calypso version of "Night and Day," with the melody almost an afterthought, powered by the precise drumming of
Philly Joe Jones. Taking "Tenderly" in waltz time,
Evans makes this familiar theme inimitably all his own. There are three more solos: two Asian-inspired interludes titled "Epilogue" and the demure and ultimately quiet "Peace Piece," a timeless, meditational, reverent, prayer-inspired composition that, in time, set a standard for chamber/classical European-tailored jazz. In an alternate/second-version bonus track,
Evans superimposes this theme under the standard "Some Other Time," and it fits beautifully. Though not his very best effort overall,
Evans garnered great attention, and rightfully so, from this important album of 1958.