Mandy Patinkin, who can wring the greatest drama or the most manic comedy out of a theater song, used only his most tender interpretive talents for his third album,
Experiment. As usual, the selections came almost exclusively from Broadway shows (the exception,
Harry Chapin's "Taxi," was a classic story-song), and one-third of them were by
Stephen Sondheim. They dated back to the 1920s (
Irving Berlin's "Always") and up to the '80s (
Claude-Michel Schönberg and
Herbert Kretzmer's "I Dreamed a Dream" and "Bring Him Home" from Les Miserables), but
Patinkin brought a consistency to them by singing gently in his trembling, innocent tenor, starting with "As Time Goes By" (complete with its rarely sung introductory verse) and ending with
Cole Porter's "Experiment." The album was in a sense one long suite or, given the brevity of many of the selections, one long medley, the songs often segueing seamlessly into each other. The album seemed designed to answer
Patinkin's critics, who had found his previous recordings melodramatic and hysterical. He was reined in on the ironically titled "Experiment," but even if this was
Mandy Patinkin Lite, it was appealing. ~ William Ruhlmann