After the orchestral extravaganza of 2004's fantastic
No Cities Left,
the Dears didn't leave themselves much room on their next album to go even bigger, lusher, more orchestral. It would be too much, and they knew it, so instead they chose to strip down their arrangements, make them simpler and less ornate. This isn't to say that
Gang of Losers is just
Murray Lightburn playing an acoustic guitar and crooning forlornly, but it does mean that
the Dears seem to have traded in their strings and horns for more straightforward electric guitar and keyboard riffs. "Ticket to Immortality," the first single, still features
Lightburn majestically singing, "I hang out with all the pariahs" (he is almost obsessed with the idea of not fitting in -- it's a theme that continues throughout the record), but it also follows a fairly standard verse-chorus type formula; there are none of the eight-minute expositions found on
No Cities Left. In fact, most of the songs are a lot more "standardly constructed," but done so in a way that keeps the band's dramatic
Queen-meets-
the Smiths aesthetic intact without overwhelming listeners with myriad undulations and structural dissections. There's still the propensity for classical resolutions and progressions, but it's much more of a rock record than their last. "Bandwagoneers" is a lovely piece with solid guitars and a smooth intensity that comes not only from the lush instrumentation but also from the fluctuations in
Lightburn's voice. He offers a wider range of emotion than he has before, moving from contemplation to anger in a single phrase ("Why can't everyone live out happily ever after?" he wonders as the song begins circling around itself, finally fading out into an electric guitar rant); equally good is the poppy "Hate Then Love," which keeps the ascending scales while still incorporating catchy melodies and simple chords. "I Fell Deep" begins with something like an interpretation of the piano riff from
Radiohead's "Pyramid Song" and turns bluesy with an organ and background chorus, almost fit for musical theater, while "Whites Only Party" is lyrically complicated but sticks to basic, quick-moving acoustic guitar and piano with a Western feel, complete with a frontier-town-inspired guitar solo. Still, everything on the album is very much
the Dears, very much how they've always presented themselves, very much what they've always done. They're a little less baroque, they're a little less depressing (maybe
Lightburn's marriage to bandmate
Natalia Yanchak helped things here), but they're just as emotional and affecting, which makes
Gang of Losers very good indeed. ~ Marisa Brown