Bonnie Raitt may have switched producers for her second album
Give It Up, hiring
Michael Cuscuna, but she hasn't switched her style, sticking with the thoroughly engaging blend of folk, blues, R&B, and Californian soft rock. If anything, she's strengthened her formula here, making the divisions between the genres nearly indistinguishable. Take the title track, for instance. It opens with a bluesy acoustic guitar before kicking into a New Orleans brass band about halfway through -- and the great thing about it is that
Raitt makes the switch sound natural, even inevitable, never forced. And that's just the tip of the iceberg here, since
Give It Up is filled with great songs, delivered in familiar, yet always surprising, ways by
Raitt and her skilled band. For those that want to pigeonhole her as a white blues singer, she delivers the lovely "Nothing Seems to Matter," a gentle mid-tempo number that's as mellow as
Linda Ronstadt and far more seductive. That's the key to
Give It Up: Yes,
Raitt can be earthy and sexy, but she balances it with an inviting sensuality that makes the record glow. It's all delivered in a fantastic set of originals and covers performed so naturally it's hard to tell them apart and roots music so thoroughly fused that it all sounds original, even when it's possible to spot the individual elements or influences.
Raitt would go on to greater chart successes, but she not only had trouble topping this record, generations of singers, from
Sheryl Crow to
Shelby Lynne, have used this as a touchstone. One of the great Southern California records. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine