Taking the hard rock inclinations of
Generation Terrorists to an extreme,
the Manic Street Preachers delivered a flawed but intriguing second album with
Gold Against the Soul. Inspired by
Guns N' Roses, the
Manics decided to rework their working-class angst as heavy arena rock; they seize upon the latent politicism of
Guns N' Roses' tortured white-trash metal, interpreting it as a call to arms. Since the Manics are more intellectual and revolutionary than
the Gunners,
Gold Against the Soul burns with inspired, if confused, rhetoric.
The Manics, however, aren't quite as gifted with hooks at this stage -- their power derives from their self-belief, which they can't quite translate into songs. They are given a bigger, louder production on
Gold Against the Soul, which makes the album a more visceral listen than
Generation Terrorists, but the songs aren't as consistently compelling as those on the debut. "From Despair to Where" is a vibrant anthem, and "Drug Drug Druggy," "Roses in the Hospital," "Yourself," and "Sleepflower" all have a similar energy, but the peaks don't arrive quite as frequently as before. Nevertheless, the rage is more articulate and the sound is stronger, making
Gold Against the Soul a flawed but worthy step forward. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine