Greatest Hits lives up to its title, offering the bulk of
Tim McGraw's big hits over the course of its 15 tracks. Thankfully, there are no new recordings to bait hardcore fans -- just "Let's Make Love," the duet with
Faith Hill that originally appeared on her
Breathe album. Consequently, this is one of the rare modern-day incidences of a
Greatest Hits that really offers all the hits, and nothing but, which not only makes it a boon to fans, but also makes it the most consistent record in
McGraw's catalog. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine