This may well be the first time the idea of historical revisionism has been invoked in the title of a bluegrass album. Despite what the title might seem to suggest, this isn't a best-of. It's their first album for the Compass label, and as it turns out it's the first part of the album title that really signifies: this is bluegrass by musicians who have matured into their talent and seem to have little to prove. The songs themselves are the focus of the music-making, and while the band's playing is absolutely tight and professional, there's precious little here in the way of high-flying technical fireworks or complex vocal harmonies. (Though we do get a bit of fancy-pants Dobro picking from guest musician
Rob Ickes.) And what songs they are: the original "Why Did You Lie" opens the program in a defiantly midtempo and absolutely perfectly heartbroken mode; a tasteful rendition of
Buck Owens' classic "Love's Gonna Live Here" (with guest vocalist
Rhonda Vincent) tips the hat graciously to the departed master of Bakersfield country; the swinging "Bubble Gum Baby" may be a trifle, but it's also a fine example of bluegrass-style Texas swing, a fusion not commonly attempted and even more rarely mastered. And if you find yourself missing the technical fireworks that bluegrass albums so often offer, the group does throw you a bone with "El Cumbanchero" -- not that it sounds like bluegrass. What it sounds like is norteño klezmer music, which is pretty dang nifty. And in the Cool Covers department, we've got
Sam Cooke's "Bring It on Home to Me," while in the Uncool Covers department, we've got
James Taylor's "Rolling Away on a Big Sternwheeler." Something for everyone, in other words. Brilliant. ~ Rick Anderson