It isn't hard to understand why smooth jazz is the whipping boy of jazz reviewers. Much of the shlock that American smooth jazz/NAC stations play is boring, mechanical, robotic, and devoid of soul. But if one considers
Grover Washington, Jr.,
David Sanborn, and early
Ronnie Laws part of smooth jazz, then one has to say that some smooth jazz has artistic merit;
Washington's
Mister Magic album, in fact,, is a classic.
Al Williams III's
Heart Song won't go down in history as a classic, but it is a generally decent, if uneven, effort that is far superior to most of the bloodless elevator music that smooth jazz/NAC programmers have favored in the 1990s and in the 21st century.
Heart Song has its dull moments:
Williams' unimaginative cover of
Simply Red's "Holding Back the Years" is among the throwaways.
Williams should have soared on that 1980s gem, but instead, his radio-oriented version is nothing more than lethargic background music. The good news, however, is that most of
Heart Song is worthwhile.
Williams is a skillful tenor, alto, and soprano saxman with a strong
Washington influence that carries over to his flute playing (which owes something to
Hubert Laws and
Herbie Mann as well as
Mister Magic), and most of the time, he successfully balances commercial and artistic considerations. Tracks like "Sun Dance," "Skylight Drive," and "Midnight in Morocco" have a lot of pop appeal, but they also have an edge and demonstrate that
Williams is aware of smooth jazz's soul-jazz heritage (
Washington, it should be noted, was greatly influenced by heavyweights like
Gene Ammons,
Stanley Turrentine, and
Eddie "Lockjaw" Davis).
Heart Song isn't nearly as risk-taking as it could have been, but it has more pluses than minuses -- and more often than not,
Williams reminds us that smooth jazz doesn't have to be mindless drivel. ~ Alex Henderson