Considerably lighter than
Madman Across the Water,
Honky Chateau is a rollicking collection of ballads, rockers, blues, country-rock, and soul songs. On paper, it reads like an eclectic mess, but it plays as the most focused and accomplished set of songs
Elton John and
Bernie Taupin ever wrote. The skittering boogie of "Honky Cat" and the light psychedelic pop of "Rocket Man" helped send
Honky Chateau to the top of the charts, but what is truly impressive about the album is the depth of its material. From the surprisingly cynical and nasty "I Think I'm Going to Kill Myself" to the moving ballad "Mona Lisas and Mad Hatters,"
John is at the top of his form, crafting immaculate pop songs with memorable melodies and powerful hooks. While
Taupin's lyrics aren't much more comprehensible than before,
John delivers them with skill and passion, making them feel more substantial than they are. But what makes
Honky Chateau a classic is the songcraft, and the way
John ties disparate strands of roots music into distinctive and idiosyncratic pop -- it's one of the finest collections of mainstream singer/songwriter pop of the early '70s. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine