Surely no one was expecting a "quiet storm" album from
Wilson Pickett in 1968, and that sure isn't what they got with
I'm in Love, but the Wicked Pickett sounds a lot more convincing on this album's romantic numbers than anyone would have had a right to expect from one of the baddest cats of Southern soul. Of course, there aren't all that many romantic ballads here, but
Pickett's rough-and-ready soul shouting manages to sound just as convincing on "Bring It On Home to Me" and "That Kind of Love" as he does on the pained "Jealous Love" and a properly intense rip through "Stagger Lee."
Pickett makes the most of the songwriting contributions from frequent collaborators
Bobby Womack and Don Covay, while
Tommy Cogbill and his crew of Muscle Shoals session heavyweights offer music which keeps up with
Pickett for guts, soul, and drive -- no small statement, considering
Pickett's richly deserved reputation as one of the strongest and most consistent artists of the period. Like most R&B albums of the period,
I'm in Love sounds more like a set of tunes than a unified album, but it's a good set of tunes, performed with
Pickett's usual high level of passion and skill, and if you're any kind of fan you'll revel in it. ~ Mark Deming