With each album,
Clue to Kalo (aka Mark Mitchell) has made significant musical strides.
It's One Way, It's Every Way added more structure, vocals, and live instrumentation to
Come Here When You Sleepwalk's delicately glitchy melodies, and
Lily Perdida sounds even fuller and livelier than
It's One Way, It's Every Way did, with brisk, bouncy indie pop that sounds more than a little like fellow Aussies
Architecture in Helsinki (who seem to be on the opposite trajectory from
Clue to Kalo, adding more electronic elements to their sound with each release).
Lily Perdida is also more conceptual than
It's One Way, It's Every Way; considering that that album was described by Mitchell as "a musical palindrome" about death, that's saying something. This album tells the life story of its titular character from birth to death, using the view points of those close to her: The Brother, The Familiars, etc. However, the music doesn't get bogged down in the concept -- in fact, it's barely apparent unless you listen along with the lyric sheet (which reveals cleverly written lines like "Lull for Dear Life -- by the Parents"' "Lily, first of three to take us over/You'll turn to grief as you grow older"). What is immediately recognizable is that this is some of Mitchell's most purposeful sounding music: where
Come Here When You Sleepwalk drifted and swirled like pixels in a digital breeze and
It's One Way, It's Every Way offered linear song progressions,
Lily Perdida is crisp instead of wispy, offering lots of immediate hooks and melodies, especially on the
Belle & Sebastian-esque "User to a Carrier -- by the Sister," the he-said she-said breakup story of "It's Here the Story's Straight" and "The Infinite Orphan," which boasts an irresistible keyboard line and hand drums. Not all of the album reaches these heights, but most of
Lily Perdida is charming -- it's like these songs were always within Mitchell's reach, but were buried underneath processing and slower tempos in his earlier work, and they're bursting out here. ~ Heather Phares