James Durbin was the default "rocker" on the 2011 season of American Idol and played the role well, covering tracks by
Queen,
Judas Priest, and others. He did not win, but finished in fourth place as a fan favorite for his soaring vocals and faux-hawked, "post-grunge meets hair metal" image.
Durbin's post-Idol debut, 2011's
Memories of a Beautiful Disaster, is much more pop than rock, and in that sense a fairly true representation of
Durbin's rock theatricality and knack for wailing away on tunes packed with radio-friendly hooks. One might have expected him to deliver a dark, post-grunge album à la his AmIdol brethren
Daughtry or
David Cook, and certainly the leadoff track "Higher Than Heaven" packages
Durbin's angelic yawlp with just enough processed electric guitar fuzz and squelch to register as nu-metal dirty. Elsewhere, listeners get a pop-friendly concoction of
OneRepublic-esque uplift cuts such as "All I Want," the veritable power pop-infused "Love in Ruins," and the anthemic ballad "Love Me Bad." Ultimately,
Durbin does deliver the vocal goods here on material that should appeal to his AmIdol fan base. ~ Matt Collar