Since
Fever to Tell, with each album
the Yeah Yeah Yeahs have challenged their audience with their changes, and
Mosquito is no exception. A 180 from
It's Blitz!'s flashy electro sheen, the band's fourth album downplays synths, programmed beats, and other gadgetry in favor of drums, guitars, and a mix of rock and inward-looking ballads that occasionally recalls
Show Your Bones.
Karen O,
Nick Zinner, and
Brian Chase reunite with longtime producers
David Sitek and
Nick Launay -- who were honorary members of the band by this point -- and they take the trio in any direction they want to go. Since "Maps," some of
the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' most exciting songs show their vulnerability.
O sounds full-throated and full-hearted as she sings "your sun is my sun" on "Despair," the kind of unabashed love song the band has excelled at since that breakthrough power ballad. Likewise, "Wedding Song" -- which
O actually sang at her nuptials -- is genuine and intimate enough to strike a near-universal chord. Meanwhile,
Mosquito's loudest songs are more playfully nostalgic than ferocious, which in its own way is in keeping with the album's often reflective tone. "Area 52" and the title track spin tales about aliens and bloodsucking bugs that are much sillier than
the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' early days; as impressive as
O's wail still is, there's a campiness to these songs that almost feels like the band is having a fond laugh about when they used to do this all the time. Indeed, they sound most engaged on
Mosquito when they're somewhere between its extremes. The lead track, "Sacrilege," showcases their way with a slow-building epic and plays like a more daring kissing cousin of
Madonna's "Like a Prayer" as
O sings "Fallin' for a guy/Who fell down from the sky" as a gospel choir rises up to meet her -- a risky move, since adding it to rock songs can be transcendent but more often than not just sounds like corny co-opting. Here, it actually works, and the way that the band incorporates dub elements on "Under the Earth" and the excellent "Slave" -- which sounds like
Siouxsie and the Banshees recording at Studio One -- and the cameo from
Dr. Octagon on "Buried Alive" are nearly as impressive. Something of a grower,
Mosquito has perhaps the widest range of sounds and moods
the Yeah Yeah Yeahs have ever presented on one set of songs. It might not be as cohesive as their best albums, but the standout songs rival their finest moments. ~ Heather Phares