Midnight Choir's second album was also the first produced by
the Walkabouts'
Chris Eckman, who would become the group's mentor and biggest booster through the '90s and beyond, helping to bring the quartet to wider attention through Europe and from there the rest of the world. His production on
Olsen's Lot readily brought out the passionate drama of
Midnight Choir, with plenty of dark shadows drawing on the same sources as
Eckman's music, whether it be the murder ballads of past America,
Leonard Cohen's haunted anti-mainstream MOR,
Lee Hazlewood's self-consciously rich and ironic albums, or the post-goth power of solo
Nick Cave.
Paal Flaata's singing right from the start aims for a commanding presence, but thankfully it never goes too over-the-top -- there's an audible catch and twang in his voice on songs like "Sister of Mercy" and "Heavy Rain" that favorably suggests fellow neo-traditionalist
Chris Isaak.
Flaata brings a ready command to the songs, all written by multi-instrumentalist
Al DeLoner, whose performance on guitar and keyboards throughout emphasizes aiming for just the right killer touch without worrying about overt flash. Check his fine efforts on "My Masquerade" or "Sailing Dark Waters" for plenty of proof, while the rhythm section of
Ron Olsen and Atle Aamodt fluidly add strong and softer performances as needed.
Eckman participates on singing and synths at many points, while fellow
Walkabouts stalwarts like Glenn Slater and
Carla Torgerson bring their varied gifts to the table as well. Regular
Walkabouts string arranger Mark Nichols, meanwhile, contributes throughout, adding a rich, haunting sheen for many songs. The whole album is a beautiful, theatrical presentation of American music that trumps both Nashville's slick '90s decline and alt-country's lack of taking chances easily. Secret highlight: "Jeff Bridges," a celebration of the actor as mythic American loner that retains a fierce, black power even at a slow pace. ~ Ned Raggett