Yo La Tengo made a major creative leap forward with 1992's
May I Sing with Me, where their yin-and-yang mix of quiet and loud finally began to work as well as it was meant to, but 1993's
Painful was where they truly hit their stride, their first album to confirm they were one of the best independent bands extant.
Ira Kaplan's buzzy guitar freakouts had made it to vinyl before, but
Painful gave them better context, with songs that were well suited to his noisy style. "Sudden Organ" introduced the Ace-Tone keyboard that would become an important voice in their music, while the droney textures of "Big Day Coming," "The Whole of the Law," and "Superstar-Watcher" were the cornerstones of a key part of the
YLT aesthetic over the next two decades. While
Georgia Hubley's drumming had been capable enough on
YLT's early sides, she played with greater confidence on
Painful and revealed a more adventurous sense of rhythm, and her vocals sounded less shy and more sweetly certain. And bassist
James McNew had fully integrated himself into the band after making his debut on
May I Sing with Me, and if his style was far from flashy, it was an ideal complement to the idiosyncratic but effective sounds
Kaplan and
Hubley brought to the table. And
Yo La Tengo were writing as well as they were playing on
Painful, and "From a Motel 6," "I Heard You Looking," "Nowhere Near," and "Big Day Coming" remain key numbers in the band's songbook. Before
Painful,
Yo La Tengo were a fine band that hadn't quite mastered the recording studio; with this album, they matured into one of indie rock's most consistently satisfying acts, and this was the first in a run of excellent albums that would stretch into the 21st century. ~ Mark Deming