Shelved during of the great record label consolidation of the early 2000s,
Patty Griffin's
Silver Bell is indeed a "lost album" but it is not one that carries mythic weight.
Griffin rebounded relatively quickly after
Silver Bell's abandoned release -- two years later, she signed with ATO and released
1000 Kisses, the first in a series of regular records all receiving greater acclaim and stronger sales -- and
Silver Bell itself strengthened her reputation and bank account due to covers by
the Dixie Chicks, who cut "Top of the World" and "Truth #2" on 2002's
Home (over a decade later,
Natalie Maines once again returned to this album for its title track, recording "Silver Bell" for her 2013 solo debut,
Mother). If
the Chicks' covers suggest that the album has a strong country flavor, that's not necessarily wrong, but there’s a roiling rock undertow tempered by a smoky, late-night soulfulness that gives this album its emotional resonance. These sounds are not mutually exclusive. Often,
Griffin blends it all together, pushing a song that starts as country into bracing, cathartic territory, a trick that is an outgrowth of
Flaming Red. Despite the success
the Dixie Chicks had with songs from this album,
Silver Bell is not necessarily a record that would've brought
Griffin to a larger audience. It is simultaneously inward and explosive, a record that demands close listening and certainly rewards the attention.
Griffin may have gotten a little more accessible not much later, but it's hard to hear
Silver Bell and not think of it as a compelling transitional LP that's the missing piece of the puzzle, the moment when
Patty Griffin inadvertently learned that the hard road not only resulted in a rewarding journey, but it was the road she was destined to take. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine