John Greaves has always done his best work in collaboration, whether in his early days in the hyper-collaborative collective
Henry Cow or later albums with the likes of
Pip Pyle,
Lisa Herman, and his primary collaborator,
Peter Blegvad. On his fifth album,
Songs, however, the parade of guest stars occasionally gets a bit overwhelming. It's more like a
John Greaves tribute album than anything else! Working with a drummerless acoustic piano/bass/guitar trio starring French pianist
Sophia Domancich, along with various guest musicians,
Greaves runs through a program of older songs and a few new ones. He does none of the singing, leaving that to friends like
Robert Wyatt (who contributes three vocals, including a stunning remake of "Kew. Rhone.") and
Kristoffer Blegvad. This isn't a bad thing in itself (
Wyatt and
Blegvad are both stunning interpreters), but it does mean that some of
Greaves' own personality is unfortunately missing from the album.
Songs will be a treat for longtime fans, but newcomers are advised to start elsewhere first for the full effect.