Despite sounding rushed to capitalize on fourth quarter sales, 2010’s
Loud proved that
Rihanna’s reign indeed would not let up. The album’s first three singles topped the Hot 100. A fourth one merely went Top Ten. Just as
Loud was losing its grip, during the fourth quarter of 2011,
Rihanna fired again with another number one single, “We Found Love” -- its success more likely due to the singer’s ecstatic vocal than
Calvin Harris' shrill, plinky production. While
Talk That Talk is built like another singles-chart-devouring machine, it’s both more rounded and less random than
Loud. “We Found Love” and “Where Have You Been” -- the latter with a quote from Geoff Mack's “I’ve Been Everywhere” and echoes of the chorus from
Adele’s “Rolling in the Deep” -- function as place-holding dance tracks, and there are a couple empty anthems and ballads in the drippy “We All Want Love” and the bombastic “Farewell.” It’s the darker and dirty-minded material that tends to be most effective -- where
Rihanna is more alive and believable, where her collaborators provide the most adventurous productions. In the
Bangladesh-produced “Cockiness (Love It),” one of the most hypnotic and wicked beats of the last decade,
Rihanna absolutely relishes the chance to sing-taunt “Suck my cockiness, swallow my persuasion.” Two of
Stargate and Esther Dean's three contributions -- the desperate,
xx-sampling “Drunk on Love“ (“Nothing can sober me up”) and the prowling “Roc Me Out” -- pack more sleek menace than
Rated R's “G4L” and
Loud’s “S&M.” The album’s best track, however, is the wholly sweet and flirtatious “Watch n’ Learn,” featuring a dizzying Hit-Boy beat -- rat-a-tat snares, swirling/swelling synthesizers, irresistible plucked melodies -- that is even more unique in the context of 2011 pop radio than his work on
Kanye West and
Jay-Z's “Ni**as in Paris.” Behind
Good Girl Gone Bad and
Rated R, this is
Rihanna's third best album to date. Minus the fluff, it's close to the latter's equal. ~ Andy Kellman