The Rose Garden's only album is a fair but unmemorable pop-folk-rock record, able in its emulation of
the Byrds' 12-string guitar sound with some competent stirring male-female vocal blends. Indeed this contains some of the most blatant mimicry of
Roger McGuinn's style that you'll find, without nearly as much of
McGuinn's imagination. Far more pop-oriented than
the Byrds, the record was also handicapped by the absence of original material; the sole song bearing writing credits of group members, "Flower Town" (on which
Kim Fowley also somehow manages to squeeze into the credit line), is in fact an adaptation of the traditional folk song "Portland Town." Big
Byrds collectors, though, might want to keep an eye out for this not-too-easy-to-find LP as it contains two
Gene Clark songs that never appeared anywhere else, "Till Today" and "Long Time." Neither of these songs are wonderful, but they're okay and better than the rest of the album (save the hit "Next Plane to London"), with "Till Today" bearing a countryish feel not unlike some of the songs on
Clark's debut album. In other curious footnotes, three of the tunes were co-written by Pat Vegas, later to rise to fame as part of
Redbone, while "Look What You've Done" was co-written by Bob Johnston, who at that time was producing superstars
Bob Dylan and
Johnny Cash. ~ Richie Unterberger