Whereas 2000's
Domestica explored the intense pain of
Tim Kasher's divorce,
Ugly Organ is a tale of empty sex, overwrought melodrama, and metaphors of which the album's title is only the first.
Kasher likes making you feel queasy, and
Cursive backs him up with unpredictable instrumental turns. "Butcher the Song" could be about a lot of things, but it's definitely not happy, and its instrumentation lurches in stops and rushing starts like a drivetrain gone bad. "Art Is Hard" is much louder. "Keep turning out those hits! Till it's all the same old sh*t!" The clattering guitars shoot backward at
Cursive's louder roots, but the knifing lyrics stab wildly at fans, the band, the industry -- any target available.
Kasher and co. are similarly restless throughout
Ugly Organ, and that sentiment makes the album both rewarding and frustrating. They're capable of great beauty, particularly in the sure hand of cellist Gretta Cohn, who first appeared on the
Burst & Bloom EP but is a true force here. She adds a soaring melody to "Driftwood: A Fairy Tale," making it sound like
Spoon with a fuller lineup. But the band also throws a thousand ideas into the wind on
Organ, and a lot of them become just hints and melodrama. The ten-minute "Staying Alive" is flush with intensity but goes in too many different directions, while the brief "Herald! Frankenstein" doesn't expand far enough.
Kasher's always pretty clear with his lyrics; he's having a post-coital conversation in "Gentleman Caller," he's the post-divorce depressive in "Recluse." But
Cursive could use a little more clarity throughout
Ugly Organ, to fully capture the band's fractured and anxious, but always exuberant sound. [The Deluxe Edition of the album released in 2014 adds a bonus disc, a big booklet filled with photos and lyrics, plus an essay by the A.V. Club's Kyle Ryan. The extra disc contains eight songs that were recorded at the same time as The Ugly Organ, but didn't make it in the album. Instead they found homes on the Saddle Creek 50 compilation, their spilt single with Eastern Youth and the ‘Art Is Hard’ and ‘The Recluse’ singles.] ~ Johnny Loftus