Like its predecessor, this second volume of
Unearthed Merseybeat is truly archeological in its excavation of 1961-1966 Liverpool-area rock. It's not just obscure; it's wholly unreleased, all 20 of the tracks seeing the official light of day for the first time here. Despite the presence of a few name bands (
Gerry & the Pacemakers,
the Swinging Blue Jeans,
the Merseybeats), it should be emphasized that this really is for serious collectors: the sound quality is sometimes rough, there are an abundance of cover versions of early American rock & roll songs, and nothing here is on the level of the best Merseybeat music, whether by
the Beatles,
Searchers, or lesser lights. Too, it's not even quite as good as
Vol. 1 of the series, in part because of the presence of a number of so-so cover versions, in part because
Vol. 1 likely creamed off the very best unreleased Merseybeat there is to be found. Nevertheless, it's a reasonably fun listen, and serious historians will relish the chance to hear those early recordings by
Gerry & the Pacemakers,
the Swinging Blue Jeans, and
the Merseybeats in particular, as all of those tracks predate anything these bands released.
Gerry Marsden and his boys are represented by a brace of 1961 cuts, those being a cover of "Whole Lotta Shakin' Goin' On" and the
Marsden original "Why Oh Why," both recorded at a church hall;
the Swinging Blue Jeans by live 1961 covers of
Duane Eddy's "40 Miles of Bad Road" and
the Ventures' "Walk Don't Run"; and
the Merseybeats by home-recorded 1962
Everly Brothers tunes. The only other group most British Invasion fans might be likely to recognize are Rory Storm & the Hurricanes,
Ringo Starr's pre-
Beatles band, though
Ringo was long gone by the time they did the 1965 version of
Carl Perkins' "Lend Me Your Comb" here. While most of the rest serves as evidence of the naïve energy '60s Merseybeat outfits brought to rock & roll, what's missing, for the most part, is the outstanding original material that made the early recordings by
the Beatles and some others from the region so significant. The welcome exceptions are the two mid-'60s numbers by the Kirkbys, which show them to be solid followers of the harmony-laden sounds of
the Searchers and early
Beatles. ~ Richie Unterberger