Diana Damrau is arguably one of the finest artists in the opera world in the early 21st century, with exquisite phrasing, drama, and heartfelt emotion. One need only hear her interpretations of German lieder, the Queen of the Night, or even
Bernstein. Yet these
Verdi canzoni are rather a disappointment, given
Damrau's prodigious talent, though
César Augusto Gutiérrez and
Paul Armin Edelmann seem to be better suited to this repertoire.
Damrau's Stornello begins this album, and there is too much scooping and added drama in the voice. The legato lines are lost, and
Damrau interprets them in a more spoken fashion. Lo spazzacamino comes across as too bright and shrill; the drama seems to be coming more from the artist putting something into the song, rather than organically coming from the song itself. Sometimes the pitch variation in
Damrau's vibrato creates a bit too much distortion, such as when she sings "Perduto ho la pace" in the song of the same name. However, here, one can hear
Damrau's beautiful lower voice, and perhaps this song succeeds more because there is more restraint in her interpretation. Brindisi (2nd version) in particular demonstrates the general problem with all of these songs: it needs more darkness and heft in the voice, and these are generally not qualities for which
Damrau is renowned. This is not to say that brighter, lighter voices should not sing
Verdi, for Gilda is not a spinto role; rather,
Damrau's voice is not suited to these particular
Verdi canzoni. Regarding the other artists,
Edelmann's baritone is tender and lyrical, as in La seduzione and in Nell'orror di notte oscura, for he evokes sympathy in the listener, he has the ability to touch you. His legato and lyricism are like that of a tenor. But sometimes, one feels that the fire and passion needed for
Verdi are a bit lacking; Non t'accostar is turned into a lied. The most successful match is
Gutiérrez with the
Verdi songs. He has more brightness and power, such as in the Brindisi and Il mistero (which is executed flawlessly), solid technique, and a consistent sound that never breaks. Sometimes his phrasing tends to run all the same, as does
Edelmann's on occasion. Overall, this is not the most ideal choice of artists for
Verdi, but this in no way disregards the great abilities of these opera singers.