Canadian singer/songwriter
Laura Barrett's first full-length recording mines the same delicate, impossibly playful alternative folk milieu as her 2006 debut EP,
Earth Sciences. Often compared to pixie harpist
Joanna Newsom,
Barrett's weapon of choice is the African thumb piano, a handheld cousin of the larger mbira made famous by South African artist
Stella Chiweshe. Like
Newsom, the intricate fingerpicking that her instrument requires yields a lush web of sound in which to lay her offbeat lyrics and sinewy melodies. Unlike
Newsom,
Barrett possesses a non-divisive set of pipes that are both pleasant and plain, recalling a young
Shirley Collins, and the 12 disparate songs that make up
Victory Garden benefit from her evenhanded delivery. Clearly versed in the scholarly side of the music world,
Barrett's melodies are both familiar and otherworldly, twisting and turning like mid-'70s
Joni Mitchell with a 21st century "freak folk" sheen, and it's a testament to her labyrinthine composition skills that the results are almost never cloying. Genres yield no property lines for
Barrett, as she gleefully skips from folk ("Wood Between Worlds") to classical pop ("Escape to the Sun Dome") to torch song ("To the Stars") without ever breaking a sweat. Even when she misses the mark, like on the warbled, off-key French experimental indie pop number "Rien à Déclarer," it's hard not to root for her. ~ James Christopher Monger