The second album from
the Hacienda Brothers, 2006's What's Wrong with Right, is cut from the same cloth as the self-titled 2004 debut from
Chris Gaffney, guitarist
Dave Gonzalez, and their musical cronies, but if the approach is very much the same, there's no arguing that they've gotten even better at fusing classic country and old-school soul into one emotionally powerful package. If one wants to pinpoint a difference this time out, the R&B side of the mixture has been beefed up, and
Chris Gaffney's vocals communicate the necessary passion and heartache with genuine force and a fine actor's sense of drama; while
Gaffney has always been a fine singer, his performances here rank with his best work in the studio to date.
Dave Gonzalez doesn't bring quite as much flashy picking to What's Wrong with Right, giving pedal steel player David Berzansky more room to move, but when he does step up, he sounds fine indeed, and the final track, "Son of Saguaro," is a great showcase for his deep and twangy licks. Southern soul legend
Dan Penn produced these sessions as he did on the first album, and he gives the music a clean and unobtrusive sound while urging some stellar work from the band. Bringing a few classic R&B numbers to the set (including "It Tears Me Up," "Cowboys to Girls," and "Cry Like a Baby") was a gamble that paid off big-time, giving the group plenty of room to shine (and
Gaffney is truly outstanding on the
Charlie Rich classic "Life's Little Ups and Downs"). The group's original tunes are fine stuff, too, especially "Midnight Dream," "The Last Time," and the title cut (which
Penn co-wrote with
Gonzalez). What's Wrong with Right is great soulful music proving that heart and passion recognize no generic boundary line, something that defines
the Hacienda Brothers' musical mission. ~ Mark Deming