Shopping has such a clearly defined sound -- spiky melodies, spring-loaded basslines, rhythms that just won't quit -- that small changes make a big impact. While All or Nothing continues the move toward a more polished style that Rachel Aggs, Billy Easter, and Andrew Milk began with The Official Body, the two albums couldn't be more different. Arriving in the gloomy climate of the late 2010s, Body rejected the era's pessimism with brisk beats and heartfelt songs that generated light and warmth. With this album, Shopping begins the 2020s with a much colder style, an interesting, if not always successful, choice for such a passionate band. Though All or Nothing's title mocks high-stakes ambition, the album is certainly cleaner and tighter-sounding than any of the trio's previous music. Taking inspiration from house and industrial music and Talking Heads, Shopping brings the precision of their playing to the fore on songs that, aptly enough, explore the impersonality of 21st century life. It's an approach that works well on "Follow Me," which cleverly blurs the line between social media sharing and surveillance state paranoia, and on "For Your Pleasure," where icy repetition and vintage '80s synths fit its mindless hedonism perfectly. Many of All or Nothing's pleasures are on the technical side. It's satisfying to hear the parts of their music bounce off of each other -- or click together -- on the nagging earworm "Trust in Us" or "Expert Advice," a dazzling musical expression of information overload. Likewise, the shapes of All or Nothing's songs echo their messages in inspired ways. On the excellent "Initiative," the synths and backing vocals on the chorus are headed straight to the top; on "About You," meditations on self-sabotage form a vicious circle, nearing The Official Body's emotional depth in the process. At times, however, Shopping don't sound as engaging as they have in the past, and the momentum of songs such as the insistent yet distant title track can blow past listeners instead of bringing them along for the ride. All or Nothing is undeniably impressive, but at the cost of some of the heart that's as vital to Shopping's music as their brilliant interplay.