You know when you encounter an ensemble name like
Quadro Hypothesis that you are going to be in speculative territory, and so it is with this Italian-German release. On the program is music by Bach, and by Mozart transcribing or imitating Bach, all of it transcribed for a quartet consisting of a recorder, an unusual viol (the lyra viol or discant viol), a cello, and a theorbo or lute. Bach certainly transcribed his own music often, and although he never used an ensemble precisely like this one, the group works well enough for both trio-sonata and keyboard textures, and it's not out of the question that people played Bach this way in the eighteeth century. Historical performance per se, however, is not what the group is after. Instead, it takes as its point of departure
Nikolaus Harnoncourt's contention that music and speech were closely linked in Baroque rhetoric, that players of the time intended to play "as if speaking," but that, paradoxically, music constituted a realm that could express the unsaid: a realm of the fantasy of reason, to use the words with which the group titles the album. The conceptual snarl becomes dense. Why should this concept be applied specifically to the fugue, which supplies much of the music on the disc? The fugue was a continuation of older forms, not a typical example of the forms of expression that gave rise to Baroque musical aesthetics. And how do the retranscribed Mozart transcriptions, originally for string trio and probably meant as exercises of a sort, fit into the whole concept? What do they have to do with music and speech? It's all pretty hard to say. The album's chief value for many will reside in the curious sound of the high viols, which impart a shimmering quality to the texture. It's something like hearing Bach played on a music box or a glass harmonica, and Profil's sound is up to its usual standard of startling clarity.