A solo album by
Carl Wilson was an extremely appealing proposition. As one of the main ingredients of
the Beach Boys' vocal sound, he certainly commanded some real attention. As a harmony vocalist, he usually sang the middle part of the pattern, with
Mike Love at the bottom and
Brian Wilson on top. The middle-range harmony is what truly made the sound work, and
Carl Wilson was a master of it. And forget about his ability as a lead singer and guitarist. "Good Vibrations," "God Only Knows," and "Surfin' USA" (and numerous other records) are impressive showcases for those skills. But this album, his solo debut for Caribou/CBS, falls sadly short of those benchmarks. Most of the songs -- co-written by
Wilson and
Myrna Smith (who also appears as guest vocalist on this record) -- are bland affairs, doing little justice to
Wilson's awesome gifts. Added to that, producer
James William Guercio (Chicago mentor, and a real talent in his own right) unfortunately saddles the record with a generic '70's "hit" sound.
Wilson's contributions, especially vocally, underline what a sad situation all this is. He actually sings like a bird. What a shame he didn't have anything to sing. For purists only.