Aaron Copland's extraordinarily popular ballets, Billy the Kid, Appalachian Spring, and Rodeo, are bread-and-butter works to
Michael Tilson Thomas, possibly America's leading authority on the composer but most definitely his greatest living exponent in concert. His repertoire has long included these scores, among many others less celebrated, and no one has better insights into
Copland's intentions, thanks to the personal and professional friendship they shared. In considering this 2005 RCA reissue of
Tilson Thomas' 1999 recordings with the
San Francisco Symphony, listeners may have confidence that they are hearing the real thing, rendered with muscular rhythms, ecstatic color, impeccable execution, and the full awareness of the ballets' history that informs the best performances. Of course, many who already have
Copland's eloquent recordings, or even
Bernstein's energetic readings, may pass by this disc on the assumption that
Tilson Thomas can do no better. However, he seems to have captured both
Copland's sensitivity and
Bernstein's vitality, and produced remarkably balanced and fresh interpretations by combining these complementary impulses. Note: for this version of Appalachian Spring, the original "Revivalist" section has been interpolated in the variations on "Simple Gifts," a pleasant surprise for the jaded. RCA's sound quality is fine, though a little soft in spots.