Critically embraced, this full-length debut from
Polvo deserves notice for its scope and imaginative guitars. However,
Cor-Crane Secret sounds brittle when compared to the work of more accomplished '90s guitar bands like
Built to Spill,
Pavement, and
Sonic Youth. More experimental than indie rock's "accessible" success stories,
Polvo could never establish a broad listenership -- even after their later, more song-driven releases that stand up to the class of their genre. This determined art rock approach is perhaps most limiting on
Cor-Crane Secret, with its sometimes unnecessary abrasiveness. Sonic envelopes are pushed to the detriment of what could be grand material as youthful enthusiasm gets the better of songs like "Ox Scapula" and "Duped." The band's tendency to meander through long patches of dissonant but artful guitar structures vigorously challenges the average rock attention span. This is probably to their credit, but
Polvo dare themselves into overpowering their own rich songwriting on
Cor-Crane Secret. ~ Vincent Jeffries