One of those British phenomena that has stayed distinctly provincial -- talk all you want about
Oasis or
Blur never cracking the U.S. charts,
Stereophonics never came close, never even managing to cobble together a cult of college students or Anglophiles --
Stereophonics managed to carve out a nice living as workaday rockers in the post-
Oasis age. They were guitar rock traditionalists in the time when
Radiohead and their happy followers
Coldplay ruled British rock, marching just outside of the Zeitgeist but appealing to thousands anyway, probably because they never tried to compete with
Radiohead's spacy explorations. Instead,
Stereophonics adapted the anthemic roar of their Welsh forefathers
Manic Street Preachers, substituting
the Manics'
Guns N' Roses fascination with a love of
Nirvana, and then made big arena rock, tempered slightly with rambling acoustic singalongs straight out of
Oasis and vague electronica-flavored pop. All this is chronicled on
Decade in the Sun: The Best of Stereophonics, the group's first hits compilation and one that traces its evolution effectively, if not quite entertainingly.
Decade in the Sun is too comprehensive to be entertaining, as it drags its heels over 20 tracks that all sound huge and hookless to those listeners not subjected to these tunes as part of the general cultural fabric. For British listeners, this is a good sampling of what they heard in the background for a decade, but
Decade in the Sun winds up convincing anybody outside of the U.K. that there are some perfectly good reasons why
Stereophonics never translated across the Atlantic. [
Decade in the Sun was also released in a CD/DVD edition.] ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine