It shouldn't surprise anyone that a band with
Corin Tucker on lead vocals would have a strong political bent, and that was certainly the case with 2017's Invitation, the first album from
Filthy Friends, her supergroup side project with
Peter Buck from
R.E.M.,
Kurt Bloch from the
Fastbacks, and
Scott McCaughey from
the Young Fresh Fellows and
the Minus 5. But for their second album, 2019's Emerald Valley,
Tucker has upped the ante, with nearly every song delivering some salvo in support of the environment ("Pipeline," "The Elliott"), in defiance of social and economic inequality ("Emerald Valley," "One Flew East"), and against the persecution of the powerless ("Angels").
Tucker certainly knows how to write and sing a solid polemic, and such things are more than timely in 2019, but the songs on Emerald Valley are a bit less graceful and a touch more sloganeering than those on the first album (or most of her songs with
Sleater-Kinney), which makes the second album less satisfying than the debut. However, as music Emerald Valley consistently connects.
Bloch,
Buck, and
Tucker make for a truly impressive guitar combination, with little grandstanding but just enough buzz and slash to keep the performances lively, and the melodies suggest the tunefulness
Buck brought to
R.E.M. without a slavish devotion to their trademark jangle (and the blues and hard rock accents that dot these tunes give the performances the right amount of heft to make them swing). Bassist
Scott McCaughey and drummer
Linda Pitmon (the latter replaces
Bill Rieflin from the first album's lineup) fill their spots perfectly, giving the music a strong foundation that lifts up the music rather than fighting against it. Emerald Valley isn't the slam dunk that Invitation was, but it's more than good enough to suggest this project has legs, and here's hoping the participants find time to cut a third album sooner than later. ~ Mark Deming