In the five years between their debut album and 1999's
Eyewitness, it's obvious that
Shades Apart have learned how to write consistently catchy melodies.
Eyewitness is a little too polished to be a straight-up punk rock record, and it sounds a little too indie to fall into the generic post-grunge category -- it falls somewhere in between. But even if they aren't exactly treading musical territory that's uncommon for the '90s, what matters most is that the band has written a strong set of songs, and that's ultimately what pushes the record over the top. ~ Steve Huey