Jimmie Dale Gilmore's debut album,
Fair and Square, established him out of the box as a major talent in the Texas country music scene, but in retrospect the record seems like a rather odd representation of his talents. With longtime friend and collaborator
Joe Ely in the producer's chair,
Fair and Square is for the most part a solid honky tonk session, with
Gilmore's gloriously wobbly tenor sounding strong and clear over a band that's not afraid to turn up the gas on numbers like "White Freight Liner Blues" and the proto-rockabilly "All Grown Up." (Actually,
Gilmore and
Ely seem to have been in a rocking mood when they cut this album, given the presence of enthusiastic renditions of "Trying to Get to You" and "Singing the Blues.") However, given his strength as a songwriter, it seems curious that
Gilmore only wrote two of the album's ten songs, though with
Butch Hancock,
Townes Van Zandt, and
David Halley all willing to contribute tunes, it's not as if anyone was forcing him to cut second-rate material. More significantly, the subtle undercurrents of
Gilmore's best material seem to have been left by the wayside, as if a coffeehouse singer/songwriter had been thrown into a dance hall and was trying to avoid getting the hook.
Fair and Square is a fun album, but it's hardly the best place to start exploring
Gilmore's brand of music. ~ Mark Deming