Pat Boone's
In a Metal Mood: No More Mr. Nice Guy was a tongue-in-cheek affair that few were willing to acknowledge. How else was one to explain a 63-year-old pop singer (who hadn't had any hits for over 30 years) suddenly covering '70s hard rock classics? By contrast, guitarist
Alex Skolnick, who had enjoyed considerable success as lead guitarist for
Testament and later
Savatage, deserves kudos for essentially scrapping his rock & roll career to study, learn, and play jazz. Upon leaving
Savatage after
Handful of Rain Skolnick enrolled in the jazz department of New York's New School University. It was there that he began to formulate his notion of applying jazz arrangements to hard rock songs by
Kiss,
Aerosmith,
Scorpions,
Black Sabbath, and
the Who. After all, since pop songs from past decades were accepted into the jazz vernacular and have since become standards, why should rock & roll pieces from the '70s and '80s not be treated similarly?
Skolnick has a point. In fact if you hadn't heard the original versions of "Detroit Rock City," "Dream On," and "War Pigs," chances are you'd never suspect that they originated as hard rock songs. While
Goodbye to Romance is, by and large, a straight-ahead jazz effort recalling the genius of
Wes Montgomery,
John McLaughlin, and
Stanley Jordan,
Skolnick unfurls his former rock & roll-isms on a couple of instances; on both the
Ozzy Osbourne-penned title track and the
Skolnick original "Skol Blues," he reminds you of his previous lifestyle with some lightning-fast guitar solos, however, more in the lines of
McLaughlin than the metal tendencies of
Testament. A young, empathetic rhythm section of John Graham-Davis and Matt Zebroski on bass and drums was enlisted to assist
Skolnick in his ambitious undertaking. They, too, perform impeccably, contributing dutifully to these "standards for a new generation." ~ Dave Sleger