A large part of
Brooke White's considerable charm on American Idol was how she was cheerfully, completely out of time -- a '70s relic hauled out of the back of an attic, dusted off, and cleaned up without regard for modernity. An element of this time warp remains on
High Hopes and Heartbreaks, her second album and first of any profile, but she's shifted her timeline somewhat, adding some sass and sweetness learned from late-'70s
Olivia Newton-John, inadvertently proving there's a big difference between Grease and
Tapestry. It's a difference that gives
High Hopes a vague feeling of putting on a show, a perhaps inevitable side-effect from being on a talent contest, one where she was judged on how she made a song her own, as she does here by imagining what would happen if
Kings of Leon's "Use Somebody" was performed by an
America fronted by
Carole King.
America provides a frequent touchstone here -- their
Harrison-esque slide guitars popping up all over the place, their "Ventura Highway" name-dropped just before
Joni's
Ladies of the Canyon -- and that's when
White is at her best, creating a dreamy soft rock for a hazy, sunny afternoon. Of course, this is the sound
White has always done best, both on American Idol and on her debut
Songs from the Attic, and when she tries to break out of this sound she gets into some trouble, wearing the disco threads of the title track quite uncomfortably and getting caught in the molasses sludge of stately ballads. Fortunately, these moments don't happen all that often -- enough to notice but not enough to hamper the enjoyment of a sweet, likeable album that largely follows through on
White's Idol promise. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine