In 1985, movie star and influential live comedian
Eddie Murphy took a risk and released a serious, all-music effort. Despite his best intentions,
How Could It Be is often marred by its lack of great material, and
Murphy's voice is thin and often lacking control. Although
Murphy's will is strong, at this point he didn't possess the chops. The best thing about
How Could It Be is his distillation of influences and established artists who assumed production and writing duties. "C-O-N Confused" nicely updates the mid-'70s
Al Green up-tempo Memphis sound. The poignant title ballad has
Murphy mining genuine drama. "Party All the Time," written and produced by
Rick James, has
Murphy simply along for the ride, benefiting from one of James' best synth-based hooks. Some of the other songs aren't so successful. The well-meaning, vaguely Beatlesque pop of "My God Is Colorblind" and the jazzy and pensive "I Wish I Could Tell You When" essentially fail due to the vocals.
Murphy brings out the heavy artillery to close the album out.
Stevie Wonder, who produced and wrote "Do I," also gave
Murphy a true gem, "Everything's Coming Up Roses." The track has
Murphy sounding more polished, and would have been more than comfortable on Wonder's In Square Circle.
How Could It Be does offer some solid tracks, but more often it displays a singer with potential and not much more.