It makes a certain amount of sense that
Ruben Studdard's second album is a contemporary gospel album. His first album, 2003's
Soulful, was pitched toward an urban soul audience, and an urban contemporary gospel album is a natural extension of that attitude, since the basic sound isn't all that far removed: the slow, smooth grooves are an uncanny ringer for the sound of quiet storm, only with a religious spin.
Studdard sings songs from and works with many of the major names in contemporary gospel music --
Bill Gaither,
Walter Hawkins,
Fred Hammond,
Marvin Winans, plus
R. Kelly -- and while there are a number of cooks in the kitchen, the resulting album,
I Need an Angel, winds up being cohesive since it's all coming from the same perspective. It's all easy-rolling, smooth, and polished slow grooves, sometimes easing by on the sound of the record, other times gelling quite nicely thanks to some sturdily written and arranged songs.
Ruben sounds considerably better here than he did on
Soulful -- the voice doesn't sound rushed or thin, it sounds like he had the time in the studio to concentrate and give good performances. He still isn't blessed with a tremendous amount of on-record charisma, but he sounds nice and grounds the album, giving it a likeable focus when it starts to sound a little samey. So, while it has no standout cuts, on the whole
I Need an Angel winds up being a bit more solid than his proper debut and suggests that
Studdard may be developing the skills that will given him an actual career outside of the confines of American Idol. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine