The release of these previously unissued, acoustic solo demos was a minor revelation for
Love fans. Ten of the 16 tracks were recorded in 1966 and 1967, including early versions of "Old Man" and "Orange Skies," as well as eight songs that never made it onto
Love's '60s albums. Of the remaining six cuts, five were recorded in 1982, and one (a version of "Alone Again Or") in 1972, although all of these were also composed in the '60s.
MacLean's best songs are still "Alone Again Or" and "Old Man," the two compositions that ended up on Forever Changes (an excellent demo of "Old Man" concludes the CD). The set as a whole, however, reveals a singer/songwriter who was comparable to few other '60s rockers, in his fey melodicism (with little if any blues/R&B influence); his transmutation of folk and flamenco influences into more pop- and rock-based structures; his unexpectedly rapid key changes and irregular lyric meter; and in his guileless vocals, which are unaffected to the point of naivete. It's kind of like a cross between
Joni Mitchell and
Jose Feliciano. Even if relatively few
MacLean compositions were permitted to interefere with
Arthur Lee's material on
Love's early albums, it seems likely that
MacLean had a substantial influence on
Lee's writing and, more noticeably, the
Johnny Mathis-like vocal delivery that characterized
Lee's vocals on Forever Changes. Presumably, lines such as "ladies should be used and simply tossed aside like worn-out shoes" (from "Strong Commitment") make the composer wince today, but there are some good songs here, such as "Fresh Hope," "Kathleen," and "She Looks Good," that would have been worthy inclusions on early
Love LPs. The material from 1972 and 1982 is quite similar -- in both quality and bare-bones production -- to the earlier demos, for those conceerned that the later stuff may be too dissimilar from the '60s performances to merit investigation. ~ Richie Unterberger