In live performance, N.Y.C. drummer
Jim Black can't help but grab a lion's share of the audience attention from his bandmates. Even in ensembles led by such stellar players as
Dave Douglas,
Tim Berne,
Ellery Eskelin, or
Chris Speed, his percussive pyrotechnics are simply riveting, and one wonders whether those bandleaders have noticed the many instances when everyone's eyes are locked on the guy back there thrashing away on the skins and adding coloristic flourishes with a host of oddball paraphernalia. Fans of post-bop are among those who sit up straight and take notice; yes, he has caused even trad jazz jaws to drop.
Black has now released his first CD as a bandleader, and he's pulled a bit of a fast one on the jazz crowd -- the eponymous debut of his
AlasNoAxis quartet skews away from being a jazz record, even an avant jazz record, much of the time.
AlasNoAxis sometimes explore the type of music the drummer's jazz-focused fans might expect; there may be some modern creative experimentation as practiced by
Berne or
Eskelin, but the avant Balkan jazz of
Tiny Bell Trio or the Mediterranean-influenced groovefest of
Pachora is not much in evidence at all. This is closer to
Black's work with
Chris Speed's yeah NO or the
Human Feel collective, but even rockier than either of those. And, whether intentionally or not,
AlasNoAxis even draw a bit from the annals of prog and art rock, with Icelandic electric guitarist
Hilmar Jensson throwing a few
Robert Fripp and
David Torn influences into the mix now and then. Wisely,
Black understands that an album such as this can't rely on his percussive skills alone; the kinetic excitement of his live performances won't transfer 100 percent to recorded media, so his composing and arranging skills will have to come into play. And come into play they do.
Black has fashioned a set of 15 mainly short pieces for his band, some even structured like instrumental indie rock tunes. There are explosive, distorted power chords from
Jensson, and ominous underlying textures are employed as undercurrents to the conventionally structured pieces as well as stand-alone ambient-flavored tracks, giving the proceedings a sense of both melancholy and unease. While saxophonist and clarinetist
Speed has plenty of wild and forceful moments here,
Black has also placed him in settings that tend to bring out the plaintive and fragile quality in his tone, creating a striking contrast when the reedman faces off against the deep growling beast of
Jensson's guitar.
Skuli Sverrisson, like
Jensson a native of Iceland, anchors the goings-on with deep basslines that settle in and move the band along or -- in the case of the impressive, loping "Optical" -- thrust against the music's prevailing currents. Of course, it may be difficult to pinpoint exactly where the current is in "Optical," as all four bandmembers seemingly occupy different universes that only intersect at the piece's conclusion. In "Icon," nearly static multi-layered atmospheric ruminations balance with a beautiful slowly unfolding melody that emerges in altered form as a solo clarinet statement from
Speed at the piece's conclusion. The following number, "Luxuriate," is given over to ominous low textural soundscapes for much of its length; the midtempo groove and pretty theme of "Boombye" become unhinged by crashing power chords from
Jensson, as
Speed places his mellow clarinet over the top in one of the album's characteristically unusual juxtapositions. The crisp and propulsive uptempo drumming that often elicits cheers from live audiences emerges most clearly on "Nion" and the unlisted portion of the album closer, "Angels and Artiface." AlasNoAxis is a great debut for
Black and his band, although those who prefer their jazz unsullied by elements of the indie and avant rock worlds may be a bit put off. Oh well, you can't please everybody. ~ Dave Lynch