This two-CD, 43-track box set is the most comprehensive retrospective of Motown's biggest female star before
Diana Ross. Although her first hit, "Bye Bye Baby," presented
Wells as a blues belter, she quickly settled into a sly and sassy groove. Subsequent hits like "You Beat Me to the Punch," "Two Lovers," and "My Guy" (all included here) made the most of her shy, seductive voice by teaming her with some great songs and production by
Smokey Robinson. Although many of these tunes were relegated to B-sides, album tracks, or even the can (11 were previously unreleased), the material -- written by Motown stalwarts like Berry Gordy,
Holland-
Dozier-
Holland, and Mickey Stevenson when
Smokey was unavailable -- is not far below the hits in quality. This is as much a testimony to Motown's overflow of prolific talent as
Wells', but doesn't detract from the consistency of this set, which includes her duets with
Marvin Gaye (as well as a previously unreleased duet with
Smokey Robinson). Includes a comprehensive essay in the photo-packed booklet, although the mysterious absence of the excellent "Was It Worth It" is a notable loss. ~ Richie Unterberger