First Zayn, then
Harry and
Niall, and finally -- nearly four years after the split of U.K. boy band
One Direction -- former member
Liam Payne unveiled his official full-length debut, 2019's LP1. Under construction since 2017, the set smartly includes all of his previously released hit singles, including the multi-platinum global smash "Strip That Down" with
Quavo, which joins fresh material that charts
Payne's bittersweet trials with love ("Remember," "Heart Meet Break," "All I Want (For Christmas)"), his robust sex life ("Rude Hours" and "Both Ways"), and a youthful, party-loving lifestyle ("Hips Don't Lie," "Weekend"). Whereas his
1D brethren managed to carve out distinct personalities with their solo albums -- Zayn's brooding R&B epics,
Harry's effortless rock star poses, and
Niall's wholesome singer/songwriter authenticity --
Payne tackles hip-hop and electronic genres but struggles to distinguish himself from the crop of similar-sounding contemporaries. Without a clear direction, the sleek pop confections on LP1 sound more like a streaming playlist set to shuffle. That's not to say the album is a total loss.
Payne works best when he has a vocal foil and, fortunately, there are plenty of guests here. Bronx-bred rapper
A Boogie wit da Hoodie contributes a clever verse on the
Ed Sheeran-penned "Stack It Up" (which, for better or worse, sounds strikingly similar to "Strip That Down," the other
Sheeran contribution), while
J Balvin injects pulsing Latin flair with "Familiar." Elsewhere, electronic producers
Cheat Codes,
Jonas Blue, and
Zedd craft uplifting dance anthems on their respective entries, "Live Forever," "Polaroid," and "Get Low." Above all, the album's best track, the gorgeous pop gem "For You," is the gift that keeps on giving. The Fifty Shades Freed single was a hit throughout 2018, boosting both
Payne and duet partner
Rita Ora, who later bundled it onto her own solo set,
Phoenix. Receiving yet another lease on life, it shines just as bright on LP1, overshadowing much of the other material in the process. Front-loaded with mostly forgettable trifles, the album is saved by this bountiful back-end, which plays like an early prediction of a potential greatest-hits collection. If
Payne can find a more distinctive vision and a team who can better utilize his strong vocals, he might get a chance for that longevity. For now, LP1 merely hints at his future potential. ~ Neil Z. Yeung